PifferPilfer
PifferPilfer
Sign in
HomeNotesArchiveLeaderboardAbout

Did Covid vaccines reduce fertility? Comparing uptake across age groups

What changes when I compare reproductive-age uptake with vaccination at other ages?

Davide Piffer's avatar
Davide Piffer
Nov 17∙ Paid

Fertility was falling in many countries before Covid, and the decline continued after the pandemic began. Between 2019 and 2024, Japan’s total fertility rate fell from 1.36 to 1.15 births per woman, and South Korea’s from 0.92 to 0.75. China’s survey-based total fertility rate was about 1.14 births per woman for the period 1 November 2023–31 October 2024.

The path has not been uniform. South Korea’s fertility rate and China’s survey-based TFR both rose between 2023 and 2024. In the EU, fertility fell from 1.38 to 1.34 births per woman over the same year, the lowest value in Eurostat’s series since 2001. The longer declines across Europe and East Asia have prompted a search for explanations. One of the most contentious is Covid vaccination.

The question is understandable given the timing. Mass vaccination was followed by lower fertility in many countries. But the same period brought infection waves, restrictions, disrupted relationships and economic uncertainty. It’s a challenge to isolate what vaccination itself might have contributed.

A country with high vaccine uptake among prospective parents usually also has high uptake among older adults. That gives me a useful comparison: among countries with similar vaccination rates at older ages, does uptake at ages 18–49 predict a different fertility trajectory?

I began with a broad comparison of 90 countries and territories. The more detailed age records let me examine this question in 28 European countries, and then add Canada, the USA and Malaysia. Comparing uptake at different ages changes the picture considerably.


Comparing uptake at different ages

I compared vaccination uptake in 2022 with observed fertility in 2024, using the total fertility rate (TFR), measured in births per woman. Choosing 2024 allows time for vaccination to precede conception and the following nine months of pregnancy.

I asked whether higher coverage at ages 18–49 predicted a larger fertility change from 2019 to 2024 after accounting for coverage at ages 50+, country differences, regional shocks and pre-pandemic economic and demographic conditions. Annual records from 2010 onwards let me check the earlier paths too.

I fitted coverage at ages 18–49, coverage at ages 50+ and the other controls together in one regression. The coefficient for ages 18–49 asks whether fertility changed more in countries with higher uptake at those ages, holding the other variables constant (Figure 1). Both vaccination age groups include men and women.

Figure 1. What the main model compares

Four inputs enter one regression:2022 coverage at ages18-49,2022 coverage at ages50+,pre-pandemic economic and demographic controls with region, and observed2024-minus2019 TFR. The ages18-49 coefficient describes its association with fertility change while older-adult uptake and the other controls are held constant. This is the main annual model at its2024 endpoint.
The main model estimates the association for ages 18–49 while holding older-adult coverage, pre-pandemic log PPP income per person, urban share, under-15 share and region constant. All these variables enter the regression together. The diagram shows the equivalent 2024-versus-2019 comparison; the annual panel estimates a separate association for each year relative to 2019. Tap or click to enlarge.

Reproductive-age uptake predicts a larger fertility decline

Across 31 countries, higher vaccine coverage at ages 18–49 predicts a larger fertility decline after I account for vaccination among older adults. The estimate is −0.065 births per woman per ten percentage points vaccinated. Its nonspatial, country-clustered 95% confidence interval is −0.119 to −0.011, with p = 0.021 (Table 1).

The estimate is also significant with the wild-cluster bootstrap, p = 0.023. That calculation repeatedly reweights countries while preserving each country’s time series. For scale, 0.065 births per woman is about 4.3% of a hypothetical TFR of 1.50, for a ten-percentage-point difference in reproductive-age coverage.

Europe alone points in the same direction. Across 28 European countries, the annual coefficient is −0.056 after controlling coverage at ages 50+. Its interval extends just above zero, −0.114 to +0.002, with p = 0.056. Figure 2 shows the annual paths with older-age uptake controlled throughout.

Table 1. Fertility change and reproductive-age uptake after controlling other ages

Annual fertility-change associations with vaccination at ages18-49 conditional on other-age uptake. International31 after controlling50+: estimate minus0.0648,95% CI minus0.1191 to minus0.0106,p0.0208. All-outside-ages controls give less precise estimates.
Coverage coefficients are births per woman per ten percentage points completing the initial vaccination course at ages 18–49 in 2022. Outcome: actual 2024-minus-2019 TFR. Every model controls coverage at the stated other ages, interacted with each year, and retains country effects, region-by-year effects and baseline log PPP income, urban share and under-15 share interacted with year. Confidence intervals and p-values are nonspatial, clustered by country. International adds Canada, the USA and Malaysia to Europe. All outside ages means 0–17 plus 50+; this loses Cyprus, Luxembourg and Sweden for incomplete child records. Bulgaria remains included; Uzbekistan is excluded. Nominal two-sided tests; no multiplicity correction. Tap or click to enlarge.

Figure 2. Fertility trajectories after controlling older-age uptake

Annual reproductive-age vaccination associations conditional on50+ uptake in Europe28 and international31. The2024 slopes are minus0.0563 and minus0.0648. All estimates shown include older-age uptake.
Every estimate controls vaccination at ages 50+ alongside the original annual covariates. Each point relates eventual 2022 coverage at ages 18–49 to observed fertility change relative to 2019. Earlier points are pre-vaccination checks; shading marks 2021–2024. Whiskers are nonspatial country-clustered pointwise 95% CIs. The mid-2010s hump remains visible. Tap or click to enlarge.

The comparison asks whether reproductive-age coverage predicts fertility among countries with similar older-adult uptake and other measured characteristics. Uptake in the two age groups is strongly correlated, so this leaves less variation to work with. I show the models without other-age uptake in the appendix.


Upgrade to read the pre-pandemic trend tests, the dose results, and the detailed European and international sensitivity checks.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
PifferPilfer

Ancient DNA, human evolution, and the genetics of intelligence, personality, and fertility — original research with a nose for surprising results.

  • About
  • Archive
  • Recommendations
  • Sitemap
© 2026 Davide Piffer · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.